ajar: (Default)
when is a door not a door? ([personal profile] ajar) wrote in [community profile] knockknock2010-02-09 07:20 pm

ONE MONTH!

I'd like to start out by apologizing on behalf of your mods for being INCREDIBLY BEHIND on plot-related stuff. We have a big ol' modly To Do list and neither of us are really on top of it. Rest assured, there is a point to those keys, and we're also planning something for Valentines Day.

But the game's been open for a while now, and we're really open to innovation and improvement. We have some of our own ideas, but we would absolutely love to hear from each and every one of you.

So, this is a post for some feedback! What we're looking for is:
- Constructive criticism regarding any issues you've had with the game or the mods so far.
- Advice for modding, or for other players to help stay active and fit in with the game.
- Suggestions, including plot ideas you're not motivated to put in the Plots post, events or memes you'd like to see organized, and any way we can help make the game better.
- Commentary on the current content of [personal profile] ajar. (Do you think activity should be higher? Do we need to be more specific about what you can/can't do? Is the application too easy/hard? Should we format our tables in a different way? Are the lack of images offputting?)
- Reasons why you're enjoying the game/your characters.
- Reasons why you're not enjoying the game/your characters.
- Adoration for your fellow players. ♥

(Just to clarify, we're not looking for crit of individual players/characters, thankyou.)

You're all from different places around the internet, and I know we'd love to hear your thoughts on anything, even if it's just personal meta about your own characters. If you're seeing this and you're only considering joining the game, we'd also welcome your feedback!

Comments are screened, but we will be unscreening them unless otherwise specified (just throw in "leave screened" or something) so as to facilitate discussion.
jeeps: (merlin ♡ you're my big fat hero)

[personal profile] jeeps 2010-02-09 10:17 am (UTC)(link)
in the realm of mod suggestions, how would you guys feel about us making up a general layout for the rooms in the hyperion and then assigning room numbers to your characters? i've enjoyed this in a few of my past games because it can be a lot of fun knowing who's playing their music too loudly next to you, or who seems to like cooking indian food above you, and who is causing a psychic feedback loop from below you. it also might help with getting people integrated into the entire setting (i.e., not just the bar) and get a sense that your character has a whole life here. thoughts?
ivoryandhorn: A black and white photo of a woman against a black background, wearing a black feathery cape. Her pale face and hands stand out starkly against the black. (Default)

[personal profile] ivoryandhorn 2010-02-09 07:22 pm (UTC)(link)
That sounds like it could be pretty cool, on all counts.
kiwikiwi: (ToV: Okay! That's wonderful! H-Haha!)

[personal profile] kiwikiwi 2010-02-10 05:18 pm (UTC)(link)
So, I waffle about asking this, because I do not feel qualified! Because I failed the activity check, sob! I have no right to complain when I cannot even meet the minimum requirements!

But anyway, my first question is: for the 2 posts/4 threads, are those 4 threads potentially contained in those two posts, or is it four threads in addition?

Only-sort-of-related:

For me, posting is like... this terrible block area. Where I go "crap I need to post... but I am distinctly uninteresting... boo." and then from there I spiral down into an unmotivated lump, like a winner |D ANYWAY, that is definitely my problem and not yours, since I agreed to the rules when I apped!

But I was wondering if one could potentially substitute more independent threads for the second post? I know that when I am psyching myself up to play, if I'm worried about having enough time/energy/courage to post, it makes me really disinclined to tag other people's posts which I then feel very guilty about :x

In my mind, the potential problem "there aren't enough posts" is easily solved: somebody posts. The problem "not enough people are playing in those posts" is ...less so. But then, it is entirely possible I am the only person with this problem. ^^a

BLAH BLAH BLAH I am sorry I am so rambly in the moring ^^;;;;
amber: (ⓖⓠ let's do this shit)

[personal profile] amber 2010-02-11 07:45 am (UTC)(link)
Those 4 threads are potentially contained in the two posts! But you make a good point. And your opinion is totally valid; we're not going to judge just because you didn't make activity, and suggestions as to how we can increase yours - and everyone's - activity overall are always welcome!

When we were hashing out rules. I actually considered that maybe a certain amount of independent threads would be a good "make-up" for a missed post, but decided that was a very complicated concept to put in the Rules, which we were trying to keep as simple as possible.

But I might talk it over with Jeeps again, because you're right; people post, but those posts generally end up with only one or two people commenting, and that doesn't really inspire people to post more! Personally, I'd rather have a small level of posts with lots of comment threads and interaction than lots of relatively empty posts. Being able to have a whole bunch of threads from commenting around instead of having to man up and post might really increase people's activity.
crescendo: (I wear boys' underwear.)

[personal profile] crescendo 2010-02-11 08:32 pm (UTC)(link)
HELLO. I AM NOT YET IN THE GAME, BECAUSE I KEEP FAILING AT FINISHING ANY OF THE THREE OR FOUR APPS SITTING ON MY HARD DRIVE (cannot seem to finish a 3rd person section, because I don't ever do 3rd person RP, though that is perhaps more my own issues and failure, rather than a reflection on the app system, i think.)
BUT GETTING TO THE POINT:

The activity rule includes two posts, right? As someone who rarely posts in the game I already play in (out of the ten characters I've played there in the past three years, I think about a third of them I've never actually posted with!), I'm sort of worried about this being a problem if/when I DO get around to getting in here. I'm far more likely to have numerous lengthy threads here and there than I am to have the motivation to post myself, even if the threads contained in said post do count as threads for activity.